AiOdds Kicker Power Rankings: The Guy Who Made the Most Field Goals Wasn't Even #1
Turns out a kicker's ceiling depends more on his offense than his own leg.
Nobody drafts a kicker with any enthusiasm. You take one in the last round, you mutter something about "streaming it anyway," and you move on with your life. Which is exactly why nobody notices when the fantasy points at the position tell a genuinely interesting story. So let's notice it.
We ranked every kicker with real 2025 volume by fantasy points. No vibes, no "he's automatic from 50" reputation tax — just who actually scored the points.
The Guy on Top Isn't the Guy Who Made the Most Kicks
1. Jason Myers (Seattle Seahawks, 17 games) — 195 points
41-of-48 field goals, 9 makes from 50+, 48-of-48 extra points. A perfect season on extra points is the quiet hero of this ranking — zero wasted trips to the line.
2. Ka'imi Fairbairn (Houston Texans, 15 games) — 190 points
44-of-48 field goals — more makes than Myers, on fewer attempts missed — but only 28 extra-point tries all season.
Look at that gap closely. Ka'imi Fairbairn made three more field goals than Jason Myers and still finished 2nd, not 1st. Why? Extra points. Myers attempted 48 of them — a perfect season's worth of trips to the line after touchdowns. Fairbairn only got 28 tries, because Houston's offense simply didn't finish enough drives in the end zone to feed him easy points.
A kicker's fantasy ceiling isn't just his own leg. It's hostage to his offense's red-zone success.
The Field Goal Machine at #3
3. Brandon Aubrey (Dallas Cowboys, 17 games) — 180 points
36-of-42 field goals, 11 makes from 50+ (tied for the most on this list), a long of 64 yards. If you want a leg with legitimate range, this is the one.
Brandon Aubrey made 11 field goals of 50-plus yards — an absurd number of long-range attempts, which tells you two things: he's got the leg for it, and Dallas's offense was stalling out in Aubrey range often enough to give him that many chances. Elite leg, middling offense. Sound familiar?
The Full Top 10
- 1.Jason Myers SEA195
- 2.Ka'imi Fairbairn HOU190
- 3.Brandon Aubrey DAL180
- 4.Cameron Dicker LAC166
- 5.Cam Little JAX159
- 6.Will Reichard MIN157
- 7.Chase McLaughlin TB149
- 8.Chris Boswell PIT145
- 9.Jake Bates DET143
- 10.Andy Borregales NE142
The whole top 10 is bunched inside a 53-point window across a full season — the tightest, most interchangeable spread of any position we've ranked. Which is the actual lesson here: at kicker, the offense in front of him usually matters more than the leg attached to him. Stream accordingly.
All 2025 regular-season kicking totals verified from official game logs, standard fantasy scoring. check every position's real 2025 leaders on AiOdds.io. Gamble responsibly, 21+ only.
More Insights
The Cowboys Had a Top-2 Fantasy Offense in 2025. They Also Had the Worst Defense in Football.
James Cook Led the NFL in Rushing Yards in 2025. He Finished 6th in Fantasy Points.
These QBs Threw a Ton of Picks in 2025. Only One of Them Actually Paid For It.
Myles Garrett Led the NFL in Sacks in 2025. Cleveland Traded Him Anyway.
Josh Allen Finally Gets a “Real” WR1 in DJ Moore — But Will It Actually Matter for His Fantasy Ceiling?
NFL's Best WR1/WR2 Duo in 2025? Rams, Bengals, or Cowboys — Let's Roast the Splits
The Bears Led the NFL in Takeaways… and Ranked 23rd in Points Allowed. Yes, Both Are True and It's Hilarious
Drake Maye Took the 4th-Most Sacks in Football… and Still Finished Top 3 in Fantasy. This Is Ridiculous.
Caleb Williams vs. Jordan Love: Who Actually Won 2025?
Dak Prescott Is the Most Overlooked QB in Fantasy — And It's Getting Ridiculous
Derrick Henry at Age 31 Is Still Running Like He’s 25 — How Is This Man Still Alive?
AiOdds 2025 QB Power Rankings: Stats Only, No Narratives, No Mercy
The 5 Most Impactful Defensive Moves Since September 2025
Which NFL Team Scored the Most Fantasy Points in 2025? (It's Not Who You Think)
Trey McBride Didn't Just Win Tight End in 2025 — He Left the Position in the Dust